The Maid: Domestic Disturbance

The Maid: Domestic Disturbance

Description image by Barbara J. Falk Associate Professor, Canadian Forces College.
  • First Posted: Apr 14 2010 07:04 AM
  • Updated: 7 months ago

This Chilean drama offers universally relevant social commentary with the tale of a miserable live-in servant.

The Maid (La Nana) might well have had the tagline, “Hell hath no fury like a maid in a mid-life crisis.” Written and directed by Sebastián Silva, The Maid tells the story of Raquel, a maid who has been working for the same wealthy Chilean family for more than 20 years. She has kept the house in perfect order, raised the kids, and nursed more than a few grudges along the way.

When, increasingly overloaded with work, she literally falls ill, her sympathetic employers insist on hiring some temporary help. Naturally, Raquel rebels by sabotaging her relief, revealing herself to be petty, vindictive, and proprietary – not surprising, given that her entire sense of self-worth is bound up in her job. She’s over 40, has no friends and no life, and is both obsessed with and depressed by the daily rituals of the household.

Raquel is subtly played by Catalina Saavedra, who won the Breakthrough Actress award at Sundance last year, and she carefully both hides and reveals the inner and external contradictions of her character. Although her anger and unhappiness bubble to the surface in various acts of passive-aggressive unkindness, she is not exactly oppressed and alienated in the traditional Marxist sense. Indeed, Raquel is complicit in constructing the barriers between herself and the family with whom she lives and works.

Nevertheless, Raquel’s keen awareness of the social distance between her existence and that of her employers is not imaginary, a point driven home by her employer’s mother’s demeaning commentary on managing “the help.” Tradition, Catholicism, and a well-defined social hierarchy exist silently as essential elements of the mise-en-scène.

Raquel holds fast to her “privileged” position and clings to their appreciation, yet is inwardly disgusted by reminders of her lengthy servitude, such as the staged birthday party, the inexpensive sweater provided as a gift, and even the obvious self-confidence and attractiveness of the eldest daughter, who occupies a special category of resentment.

The film will no doubt be both mysteriously enticing and appalling to North American audiences, who sanctimoniously reify the middle class to which we all claim to belong, despite differences in income and occupation. Silva deftly invites the viewer into the life of the live-in domestic, and the film displays all the trappings of Chilean economic success and modernity, although almost entirely shot within familiar interior spaces – the kitchen, hallways, and bedrooms of the family home.

However, as the processes of economic and cultural globalization cause the developed and the developing world to more comfortably coincide alongside and inside one another, such domestic dramas could just as easily be imagined in New York’s Upper East Side or the wealthier neighbourhoods of urban Canada, such as Westmount, Shaughnessy, or Rosedale.

TAGS: Arts

Comments

LATEST NEWS

Latino Employment in U.S. Up To Pre-Recession Levels

Half of net new jobs in the U.S. since 2...

India Completes First Polio-Free Year

Education programs geared toward dispell...

PETA Lawsuit Names Five Orcas as Plaintiffs

Do we really want the ocean's smartest p...

Santorum Sweeps Minnesota, Colorado, Missouri

The Republican race is wide open once ag...

Last First World War Veteran Dies

Florence Green, 1901-2012....

Wal-Mart vs. Target, Canadian Version

Wal-Mart expansion signals a renewed rac...

Iran Bans Simpsons Toys

But Superman and Spider-Man are fine bec...

Chilling Video of Homs Emerges as Syrian Shelling Ramps Up

Hundreds of civilians in the seat of the...

760 Million-Year-Old Sponges Were World's First Animals

A new discovery puts the date of the fir...

Celine Dion's Husband Buys Schwartz's Deli

Thousands of Montrealers now forced to d...

Poll Suggests Obama Has Clear Edge over Romney

Obama's approval ratings might not be to...

play

FEATURED VIDEO

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks.  Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.

The Life of a News Anchor: Better Than You Thought

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks. Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.