By Northerners, For Northerners

By Northerners, For Northerners

Description image by David M. Brock Public policy strategist currently living in the Northwest Territories.
  • First Posted: Nov 06 2009 16:53 PM
  • Updated: 7 months ago

Public policy dialogue about the North tends to centre on despair. But when northerners talk northern governance, hope is the dominant theme.

Public policy dialogue about the North often centres upon themes of power or themes of despair.

The topics are so commonplace that they require minimal explanation: sovereignty and resource development or education and poor health. Public policy dialogue in the North rarely follows the same conceptual patterns, especially when the conversation is initiated by and held between northerners.

The Northern Governance Policy Research Conference held this week in Yellowknife was an exceptional example of a dialogue between northerners about the future of the Canadian North.

The conference brought together a diverse mix of scholars, community leaders and elders, elected chiefs, government policy makers, and committed activists.

Given the small pan-territorial population, one could be forgiven for expecting the same faces at this gathering as have appeared at so many conferences past.

Not so.

New faces of northern governance, policy, and research are emerging.

This is not to say that these people were lacking in familiarity.

In fact, one need only scan the list of presenters to recognize names familiar to many: Rhodes, Trudeau, Gordon, Donner. These names signal some of the most prestigious scholarships available today, and they are held by northerners who are studying at the world’s best universities as well as working with northern community organizations with the intention of doing research that may, someday, contribute to the advancement of northern governance.

Evidence from this conference suggests that a significant contribution is already being made.

One of the reasons why people get excited about northern governance is the sense that there is an opportunity to (re)design governance models that have the cultural-political power to break the heavy burdens of colonization.

One does not use a word such as colonization lightly. It elicits notions of slavery, subjugation, and oppression. And yet, this is exactly the frame within which many Aboriginal people in the north – and indeed in the rest of Canada – have come to understand their experience in North America over recent centuries.

This conference was not intended to inspire anti-colonial activism. The Aboriginal rights revolution that began in the 1960s, and was captured in speeches made during the Berger Inquiry and in arguments made during land claim negotiations, carried the anti-colonial message with strength.

Even in a post land-claims environment, the notion of colonialism does not disappear entirely.

Indeed, a theme pervasive at this conference was decolonization.

In many ways, decolonization is more difficult to achieve than rights recognition. The fight for indigenous rights in Canada sacrificed the health and lives of many activists, and one should not underestimate these struggles and achievements, and the struggle for decolonization can be just as traumatic but harder to see.

Decolonization does not come with a signing ceremony and new infrastructure. It comes after long periods of reflection and continuous attention to one’s way of knowing.

Decolonization is a movement of the mind.

Many people at this conference were advocating for notions of decolonization to be adequately reflected in governance-focused research and policy making. Already there are some distinguished examples of success.

The creation of the Carcross/Tagish First Nation’s Family Act is an excellent example. The Carcross/Tagish recently acted upon the option to establish their own legislation to govern family matters. They did not wish to simply act quickly in order to gain jurisdiction and adopt mirror legislation. Instead they engaged in a thoughtful process of thinking through the cultural-political philosophy that would underpin the Act. The result is a revolution in law. It is a piece of legislation nearly 150 pages in length, brief in its use of western legal text, and long in its reflection upon Carcross/Tagish values and stories about how families should conduct themselves.

An undertaking of this magnitude requires more than legislative drafting – no easy feat in itself – but also considerable research and consultation to rediscover Carcross/Tagish ways of knowing and acting.

Another example comes from the Northwest Territories. This time from the Tlicho, who secured self-government in 2005. A team of researchers from Tlicho communities spoke of their tireless efforts to engage youth in their communities in a dialogue about safe sexual practices. Sexual activity is a personal and sometimes taboo subject in many communities in Canada and thus not an easy policy area to work in.

The Community Action Research Team, a part of the Tlicho Community Services Agency represented at this conference by Cody Mantla, Leona Lafferty, and Anita Daniels, all of whom are young Tlicho, undertook extensive survey work, employing sound statistical methodology, to find out what young people needed; they then asked young people what they wanted. They also engaged community elders in a conversation about the risks faced by youth. They found strong support from the elders. The result has been a multifaceted program that uses social media, outreach, and dialogue to reduce risks of sexually transmitted infections.

Land claim and self-government agreements are slowly being completed. More hard work will follow.

Figuring out how to devise governance arrangements backed by rights and informed by decolonized mind sets will be personally and politically challenging. The research being undertaken by northerners today inspires hope that policy will again matter to the people of the north, because it will be our policy.

TAGS: Politics

Comments

Re:Marks

rules of engagement

I was delighted to read David Brock's comments on the conference. I lived and worked in the NWT between 1975 and 2000 and currently work on research and evaluation of post-conflict peacebuilding internationally, with a particular focus at this time on Somaliland, Bosnia, and Congo. I see many linkages between the Northern experience and that of many countries and peoples in Africa. Consensus governance, for example, offers an alternative in many states where political parties have combined with traditional social structures in a way that makes effective governance very challenging. By working together, aboriginal self-governance and public governance institutions are creating new approaches and structures that offer hope to a much more diverse constituency than just northern Canada itself. While northern Canada has never experienced conflict in the sense that many African countries have done, the concerted assault on aboriginal languages, customs, and social and family structure that was a part of early governance in the north had a long-term effect that is not much different, in my mind, from the effect that civil conflicts have had in many African states. The evolution of governance in the north has been achieved, at least in part, by people willing to come to terms with what this history has meant for individuals, families and society, and to heal from the wounds it has caused. Many places in Africa face similar challenges of linking healing from the wounds of colonialism and the evolution of participatory and effective governance. Now I often talk about how I effectively saw the start of the NWT's movement from an internal colony of Canada to responsible and effective governance that respects aboriginal cultures, traditions and histories, and that was done in partnership. During the 20th century, governance moved from an inter-departmental meeting of civil servants in Ottawa, to a northern-based institution that was gradually run by elected rather than appointed representatives and in which - after much debate - aboriginal residents chose to become fully involved, to exploring what locally-controlled governance may look like at the territorial level. Aboriginal governance also evolved – from the days of the Treaty parties through the negotiation of land claims to the acceptance of aboriginal self-governance by the government of Canada, including the creation of Nunavut as a public government created in fulfillment of aboriginal rights. So much has been created over the years that it sometimes is difficult now to think back to the Carrothers Commission, when some of the communities where it was holding hearings didn’t appear on the Canadian map. Or to 1975, when the first fully elected Council in NWT history met in Yellowknife - 55 years after the Council was created. Or to when Mr. Justice William Morrow heard testimony from people who saw the signing of Treaty 11, as part of deciding on an application for a caveat on Crown land filed by the chiefs of the Mackenzie Valley. Then, it was often difficult to see the overall patterns; now, looking back, it is possible to analyze this history in a way that can be useful for the post-colonial states elsewhere that face similar challenges. Dialogue ideas with other parts of the world also may suggest ideas for the continuing evolution of northern governance. Other parts of the world have come up with ingenious solutions that blend tradition with institutional governance. Somaliland, for example, has a House of Guurti or traditional elders; this Somaliland Senate plays a key role in protecting and preserving a hard-won peace. The idea of an aboriginal senate was proposed in Canada but never instituted. I hope Canadians will consider, as part of our foreign policy and international development, sharing some of the northern governance story and solutions with countries and people in other parts of the world who face similar challenges. One constitutional scholar says northern consensus governance is one of Canada’s finest, even if little-known, exports. Kind regards, Rosemary Cairns

Rosemary Cairns

LATEST NEWS

Kobayashi Wolfs Down 332 Wings in Half-Hour

We're not worthy! We're not worthy!...

American Job Numbers Up, Canadian Numbers Down

Are we beginning to see a reversal in th...

Roseanne Barr Running for President on Green Ticket

Blue-collar comedienne reminds us once a...

Two out of Every Three Tweets Are Useless

But not your precious little snowflake o...

U.S. No-Fly List Doubles in One Year

Three cheers for the ever-expanding defi...

Will The NHL's Concussion Problem Become an Insurance Problem?

Reports suggest insurers don't want to c...

Russian Presidential Candidate Wants To Be 'Tsar'

Fed up with westernizations such as the ...

See the Dark Side of the Moon

... without paying $400 to see Roger Wat...

Facebook Expected To File IPO Today

The world waits to find out how much Zuc...

Neil Young, Steve Jobs and A New iPod?

The boomer pair bonded over their mutual...

German Satellite Just Missed Crashing into Beijing

At this point, our orbit is one giant in...

Romney Trounces Field in Florida Primary

Four states down, 46 to go....

play

FEATURED VIDEO

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks.  Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.

The Life of a News Anchor: Better Than You Thought

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks. Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.