The Future of Venture Capital in Canada

One of my favourite Sopranos characters once told Tony Soprano that he was at the "precipice of an enormous crossroads." It's beginning to feel like that in Canadian venture capital. The Canadian Venture Capital Association recently released 2009 data indicating that deal activity was at its lowest level since the mid-1990s. This is not a uniquely Canadian phenomenon, but the drought in new venture financing has seemed longer and drier in Canada than elsewhere. In some sectors, earlier-stage investors have become more visible, but what was once concern in the industry is now escalating to alarm, as more players ask what is to become of the Canadian innovation economy.

What's more, our neighbours to the south continue to lead the way in innovating venture finance. New models of technology incubation and seed finance seem to emerge in the United States every day, as those on the hunt for opportunity continue to explore how best to develop it. Indeed, there is now a move afoot in the U.S. to change immigration law to create a "Startup Visa" that would create new opportunity for immigrant entrepreneurs to remain in the U.S.

Where should entrepreneurs in Canada turn now? We have a national record of innovation that is unrivaled, and our universities are among the best in the world, but without a rich financial ecosystem to sponsor innovation, opportunity will certainly migrate elsewhere. Many Canadians involved in these areas believe we need to act now. In its recent budget, the Federal Government announced revisions to certain aspects of Canadian income tax law that many believe have impeded foreign investment in Canadian innovation. This is a welcome development, but arguably of little relevance to home-grown sources of innovation capital.

Today we turn to an exploration of these issues, and invite you to join with us. We've assembled a diverse group of talented and experienced entrepreneurs, investors, and strategists to give us their thoughts on the challenges we face in venture capital. We hope you'll take part.

number of articles in series
Creating a Venture Culture

Creating a Venture Culture

Description image by David Crow Creative Technologist and Technical Marketer.
  • First Posted: Mar 16 2010 16:19 PM
  • Updated: 3 months ago

Canadian entrepreneurs need to take responsibility for their industry, not blame others for its failures.

We don’t have a venture capital problem, we have a culture problem!

Canada has a lot of things going for it. We have a close geographical proximity to the economy that drove most of the growth for the past century. (I might argue this is a weakness not having close proximity to Chindia). We have good universities. We have strong intellectual property rights. We have an advanced economy. And we have generally favourable tax laws (though this is debatable, and many would argue that Section 116 helps keep foreign investors out of the Canadian market helping to augment the perceived venture capital problem). We have a diverse population and active immigration policy of foreign professionals.

What we have is a culture problem. We like to play the "blame game.” It’s the fault of government, of policy, of taxation law, of the investors.

As entrepreneurs we need to take the responsibility. Venture capitalists have their own issues and their own fights. The venture capital industry in Canada has fallen on hard times. But this reflects a global downturn in venture returns. The 10-year period between 1998-2008 was not kind to Canadian VCs, their average 10-year return of 1.8 per cent was dismal when compared to the U.S.

But we need to understand that they are not the panacea, they are not the silver bullets to the challenges and struggles. They provide a very valuable service to a small set of companies: growth capital.

“The reality is that VC’s have one goal – to maximize the amount of money they return to their investors.” - Steve Blank

Venture capital is just one part of the larger ecosystem that needs to be built and supported in Canada. As entrepreneurs we need to change our culture. We need to accept responsibility for our own fate. We need to strive to find sophisticated customers and create vibrant entrepreneurial cultures.

Sophisticated customers

We need to get out of our ivory towers. We need to stop relying on SR&ED, IRAP, and other tax credits that support an ecosystem of zombie startups. This doesn't mean that they are not valuable programs and cannot be used by entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs need to understand that these programs are not operational lifelines. They are designed to support research and development. SR&ED is a research imperative. It is not a growth or operational capital solution. They are about industrial science and invention. We need this but let’s not mistake it for creating customers or markets. We need to teach entrepreneurs the difference between invention and commercialization. Between finding out if you have a solution to a problem, and whether that problem has customers and a market.

We need to find real customers. We need to find real markets. These customers and markets don’t need to be located in Canada. In fact, Canada can often serve as a providing ground, an incubator, for a variety of market segments. We need to leverage the unique attributes of a diverse population of immigrants for the creative tension of differing viewpoints, and to help forge connections with remote markets.

Venture capital is something you raise after you've tested your market and product hypotheses with real customers. You raise money because you think you’ve found a product/market fit and you want to scale. Venture capitalists can’t help you determine if you’ve got a product that meets the needs of a market, but they can help you grow. Canada provides a unique opportunity for access to sophisticated global customers and proximity to the largest economy of the past century.

Vibrant entrepreneurial cultures

We need to build a culture of connections.

It is the force of thousands of butterflies flapping their wings. All of the blogging, tweeting, attending conferences, showing up to events, participating online. It’s about the DemoCamps, Launch Parties, StartupDrinks, Social Media Breakfasts, Third Tuesdays, Founders & Funders, NEWTECHs, SproutUps, Meshes, and everything else. It is a cumulative effect. It doesn’t take a lot of extra effort, but it adds up to the rest of the world paying attention to the noise.

But it is up to us, as entrepreneurs, to make noise. It’s up to us to build successful companies. It’s up to us to make Canada a better place for startups. No one is going to walk in and make it easier. We all have to participate and build a vibrant entrepreneurial culture. We need to talk about entrepreneurship as a career path. We need to talk to politicians about policy decisions.

So the first rule of being an entrepreneur is to reach out. Invite a friend. Make a connection. Tell a customer. Most of all, do the things that make the ecosystem better for you.

TAGS: Business

Comments

Re:Marks

rules of engagement

And it's up to the VC's to raise more aggressive funds for funding early stage startups. The reality is that entrepreneurs sit at the lowest end of the VC value chain. They are the recipient of what's available out there. The rest trickles down from it.

William Mougayar

"We need to get out of our ivory towers. " "We need to teach entrepreneurs the difference between invention and commercialization" Who are you preaching to - university students? Exactly who is in the ivory tower with such motherhood and apple pie advice. Ya, and in addition to going out and selling product and building markets, I am also going to spend time talking to politicians about policy changes? That's like playing Mozart to a cow. Good luck with that. I am sure that my investors and VC's would think that is a good use of my time. Sorry to be so cranky, but this post is way too preachy to do much good for anyone.

Kerry Thacher

Hey Kerry, Thanks for the feedback. Re: Ivory Towers - University commercialization departments and government programs. They definitely have a place in the larger ecosystem however, we too often rely on them as the only source of success. This is a market driven activity. The market, i.e., customers, should determine success not the ability to find government money or through existing/past relationships with these institutions or individuals associated with the programs at institutions. "Ya, and in addition to going out and selling product and building markets" - I may not have explained this clearly. Markets. The market for your product or service. You can sell into an existing marketplace, however, you need to build the market for your product. Hope that LibreStream continues to experience success.

Some years ago on the opening of the Design Exchange, I coined the phrase, "We need a Culture for Innovation, and the climate to sustain it." And while yes as entrepreneurs we have a role to play in creating that sustenance, one of the critical areas that could improve the situation is teaching - at all levels. Entrepreneurship is simply not considered a legitimate career path; it is not included in high school guidance options, and at most universities, it is actively scorned (except in engineering). Changing teacher perceptions is not easy nor quick and at this point I would argue that very few see the need. John Arnott Executive Director Innovation Enterprise

John Arnott

LATEST NEWS

Last First World War Veteran Dies

Florence Green, 1901-2012....

Wal-Mart vs. Target, Canadian Version

Wal-Mart expansion signals a renewed rac...

Iran Bans Simpsons Toys

But Superman and Spider-Man are fine bec...

Chilling Video of Homs Emerges as Syrian Shelling Ramps Up

Hundreds of civilians in the seat of the...

760 Million-Year-Old Sponges Were World's First Animals

A new discovery puts the date of the fir...

Celine Dion's Husband Buys Schwartz's Deli

Thousands of Montrealers now forced to d...

Poll Suggests Obama Has Clear Edge over Romney

Obama's approval ratings might not be to...

Super Bowl, Madonna Light Up Twitter

But both couldn't come close to the reco...

Kobayashi Wolfs Down 337 Wings in Half-Hour

We're not worthy! We're not worthy!...

American Job Numbers Up, Canadian Numbers Down

Are we beginning to see a reversal in th...

Roseanne Barr Running for President on Green Ticket

Blue-collar comedienne reminds us once a...

play

FEATURED VIDEO

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks.  Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.

The Life of a News Anchor: Better Than You Thought

This is apparently what news anchors (at least cool ones) do during commercial breaks. Reminiscent of the coordinated dance routines our own news editor Mike Barber performs after a few beers.